"These insights will help firms strengthen their claims handling processes, so claims are dealt with promptly, clearly and fairly in line with existing rules."
- Chris Knight - FCA
A new joint thematic report on insurance claims handling by the Financial Ombudsman Service (FOS) and the FCA has identified claim delays, poor communication and customer service as the leading causes of insurance complaints over the last five years.
Between 1st April 2021 and 31st March 2026, approximately 66,000 of the 214,800 complaints received by the FOS were concerning these issues. The FOS upheld half of complaints regarding claim delays, compared to an average of 34% for the whole insurance sector.
The report aims to "help firms understand how real-world complaints connect to regulatory expectations and identify practical learning that can support better outcomes."
It calls on insurance firms to "evidence compliance with the relevant FCA rules throughout the claims journey", demonstrate "prompt and fair claims handling", and keep clear records of communications and delays.
In addition, the report urges insurers to provide "appropriate progress updates", intervene when claims stall, take responsibility for delays and work done by third parties, inform customers of "who owns the next step", and let them know when they can expect an update.
Adapting communications early for vulnerable customers with additional needs is also called for in the report, as well as ensuring urgent or sensitive cases are escalated swiftly, including by third parties.
The joint thematic report is the first in a regular series aiming to help firms improve complaints handling, and is part of a wider set of reforms designed to give firms and consumers greater transparency and certainty.
"This is the first in a regular series of thematic reports bringing together complaints data and insight from our casework with the FCA’s regulatory perspective," James Dipple-Johnstone, chief ombudsman at the FOS, said.
"The reports are designed to help firms learn from complaints, understand regulatory expectations and strengthen their complaints handling.
"By sharing practical insight, we aim to support better outcomes for consumers, help firms resolve disputes earlier and give everyone using the redress system greater clarity and confidence."
Rachel Lam, interim ombudsman managing director at the FOS, noted that those making an insurance claim "are often dealing with disruption and uncertainty," and that "avoidable delays can make a difficult situation harder, especially when customers are left chasing for answers.
"Where complaints involve delays, communication or supporting customer needs, firms should be able to show how they met the rules on prompt and fair claims handling, clear information, appropriate progress updates and delivering good customer outcomes."
READ MORE: AMI calls on industry to get involved in new commitment charter
Chris Knight, director for insurance at the FCA, acknowledged that "most insurance customers receive a good service, but we know there is room for improvement - and when standards fall short, firms must put things right.
"These insights will help firms strengthen their claims handling processes, so claims are dealt with promptly, clearly and fairly in line with existing rules.
"It builds on our ongoing work to improve claims handling and help consumers understand what their insurance covers. We will continue to act against insurance firms where we have concerns.”
James Daley, managing director of Fairer Finance, said that the report "lays bare the very real problems in the insurance claims space. While many in the industry dismissed the Which? super complaint, this latest data validates many of the concerns they raised last year.
"Far too many people are left out of their homes as repairs drag on, or left fighting to reclaim hefty medical costs after falling ill overseas. Many insurers are clearly not delivering in these key moments. The fact that 50% of complaints about claims delays are being upheld by the Ombudsman shows that insurers’ complaints teams are also part of the problem.
"It’s barely 15 months since the FCA completed its review of home and travel insurance claims. Many of the issues that have been highlighted in this latest report were barely touched on a year ago - which shows the FCA did not do a thorough job.
"We do now at least have fresh evidence that there is a problem here - and it’s vital that the FCA gets stuck into fixing the root cause of these.
"The lack of independence of loss adjusters is a key part of the problem - and the absence of any reliable data on who is driving good claims outcomes also means that consumers have no idea who they can trust."
